domingo, 13 de mayo de 2012

What's Your Motivation?


            There are several situations that potentially challenge the idea that all genes, along with their survival machines, are completely selfish. One of these such questions is the tendency for several species of animals to live in associated groups. For example, "Birds flock, insects swarm, fish and whales school, plains-dwelling mammals herd together or hunt in packs."(p.166) Why exactly does this happens? And how does it not contradict the selfish gene theory?
            The answer to this is actually quite simple. The reason that animals tend to "bunch" together, is solely for their own gain. "There is no altruism here, only selfish exploitation by each individual of every other individual."(p.168) Traveling in groups provides more protection than being alone. If they are being hunted, standing in large numbers not only diminishes each individuals chances of being the predators victim, but they also benefit from the mutual protection that being part of group naturally provides. Some animals tend to call out when they sense danger. Although, at first glimpse this might seem like an altruistic action, risking oneself to warn others that they should take cover, be cautious, or flee. However, it actually has a strong selfish connotation. When an animal such as a bird calls out to its fellow group members in the presence of danger it can usually be attributed to three different causes. The 'kin-selection idea', the 'cave' theory, or the 'never break ranks' theory. (p.169) The kin-selection idea mainly refers to the natural tendency that relatives have to protect each other, since many of their genes are similar and each other's survival is beneficial for the continuation of their genes. The cave theory consists of warning others to diminish the possibilities of having ones own chances of survival incriminated. To avoid detection by the predator, an individual can't only hide themselves, the whole group must hide, therefore the best way to do this is to call out to the others. The third theory is the never break ranks theory. According to this theory if an individual flees alone, then it is singling itself out and forfeiting the advantages of being in a group. 
            There are others situations that also appear to have altruistic characteristics. For example, hymenopterans, which are a large order of insects that include bees, wasps, ants, and sawflies, have an interesting reproductive system in place. Under this system one queen produces all future generations, while the worker organisms tend and serve her. However, in reality the reason they do this is because, "if you are a hymenopteran female, the most efficient way for you to propagate your genes is to refrain from breeding yourself, and to make your mother provide you with reproductive sisters and brothers in the ration 3:1." (p.176) Other relationships that might appear altruistic are symbiotic relationships, which is an interaction between two different organisms living in close physical association, typically to the advantage of both. Among these relationships is the interaction between Aphids and Ants. Aphids provide the Ants with juice extracted from plants in exchange for protection. Cleaner-fish decontaminate larger fish and in exchange they get a meal. Other animals develop 'mutual back-scratching arrangements'. The objective in these relationships is for fellow group members to groom the places where single individuals might have difficulty reaching, such as the head. If an individual has a tick in this spot the other member can safely remove it. Yet, for the relationship to work effectively the individual who was being groomed first, must then groom the other one and remove any harmful parasites. 
            What all these examples boil down to is the irrefutable fact that no matter how helpful an action might seem it is always driven by a selfish desire. If a school kid shares their lunch with a peer that forgot to bring theirs, it's only because they count on having the favor returned. Individuals don't do favors for others unless they benefit in some way or form. Of course it would be peasant to think that individuals look out for each other and that they do favors just because they want to help. However, that is simply not the case. All action is driven by motivation. Motivation originates in your genes. From a gene point of view passing themselves on is the most important goal, therefore the survival of their respective survival machine is always in their best interest. If they see a way to increase chances of survival then they will always opt for that path. Therefore, developing symbiotic relationships and living in groups is just a selfish way to proliferate the likelihood of survival. "In general, associations of mutual benefit will evolve if each partner can get more out than he puts in."(p.183)



domingo, 6 de mayo de 2012

Genes Moult Their Humans



It's curious how in genes being selfish is a favorable quality. From a young age, children are taught that sharing is caring. That being altruistic is essential to develop into a good human being. As kids grow older they are encouraged to put themselves in the position of others. Not judge anyone until they have walked a mile in their shoes. Always thinking about how others may feel, or how certain actions will positively or negatively affect others. 

However in the case of genes, being alturistic is clearly a negative quality. For survival means genes must think selfishly. They must constantly think of what is best for them. What they can do to outsmart their competition and manipulate other genes in their environment so that they will benefit from them. "At the gene level, altruism must be bad and selfishness good."(p.36)

In The Selfish Gene, Richard Dawkins also explores the idea that we are simply the survival machines of these genes. Created by them, and then used by them until we die, which at some point we inevitable will. He highlights how truly temporary human life is in respect to genes. "They are replicators and we are their survival machines. When we have served our purpose we are cast aside. But genes are denizens of geological time: genes are forever."(p.35) 


Metaphorically, we are only as important to genes as a snake's outer skin is to the actual snake. These animals are constantly growing out of their shell. As time transpires, snakes shed their outer covering and grow a new one. The old one is simply left in the dust, now that it has outgrown its usefulness. We work much the same way. The genes create us and make us stable enough to reproduce and pass the genes on to a new body. Once we do though, our job is done. We will die (of old age if nature allows it) and that is that. Genes live on and we as individuals simply die. Of course exact chromosomes won't be identical in future generations, but the genes remain mostly intact. "The genes are not destroyed by crossing-over, they merely change partners and march on. Of course they march on. That is their business."(p.35)
Even though some people may disagree, in reality we are factors manipulated by genes. They create us, they make sure we reproduce, and afterward they let us die. It is not necessarily intentional, but it is the way that the world works. We tend to say that genes are ours. Claiming, that our children have our genes for this and that. Yet in reality, genes clearly don't belong to us. In fact, we belong to the genes. We are just their disposable, protective covering that delivers them from generation to generation. 

The Rudimentary Gene


In The Selfish Gene, Richard Dawkins begs the question, “How did everything come to be?” At the very beginning of time atoms were mixed together in a loose sort of soup. These atoms eventually began to link up to form molecules. Then, these molecules developed the ability to replicate themselves. This was important because they could now increase their number in the general population.
Similar to Darwin’s idea of “survival of the fittest”(p.12), these early molecules were exposed to a process Dawkins deems “survival of the stable”(p.12). The gist of this process is that each of the molecules was up against the others in a type of competition. The failure or success of each depended on several characteristics. “[Certain] types would become relatively numerous in the soup, not only as a direct logical consequence of their ‘longevity’, but also because they would have a long time available for making copies of themselves.”(p.17) “Another property of a replicator variety that must have had even more importance in spreading it through the population was speed of replication or ‘fecundity’.”(p.17) The faster each molecule could replicate itself, the more identical replicas it would contribute to the soup. “A third characteristic of replicator molecules which would have been positively selected is accuracy of replication.”(p.17) If a molecule makes frequent mistakes then the copies it makes won’t be identical, therefore lessening its numbers, making it scarcer, and possibly leading to its extinction. 
However, for a molecule to be truly successful it had to have all three characteristics. Those that did, survived and began to build “survival machines for themselves to live in.”(p.19) At first these were rudimentary coatings at best, yet steadily they became stronger and more complex. “Now they [the replicators] go by the name of genes, and we are their survival machines.”(p.20) Clearly, it was a competitive, difficult process, but essential nonetheless. So essential in fact, that these early replicators have evolved into the basis for all life on earth. 

sábado, 25 de febrero de 2012

Voltaire's Truth


Voltaire ends the story in a curious manner that revokes the character’s views and instead clearly expresses his. Voltaire shows that regardless of a person’s position in society they are just as likely to suffer misfortunes. “That old fellow…seemed to have done much better for himself than those six kings we had the honour of supping with.”(p.143) Although the kings were of a high position, that didn’t save them from experiencing hardships and the fact that the other was just a commoner didn’t condemn him to an everlasting amount of troubles.
            Similarly, the different characters in Candide all had their share of evils. Regardless that they were all different, one the daughter of a Pope and Princess, one the greatest philosopher in all of Westphalia, another a beautiful young lady turned ugly with time, another a simple servant and so on, none led a life free of difficulties. They all had their own tragic tales to their names and they all ended up toiling on the very same farm.
            Voltaire’s last concrete lesson is that all the characters’ views were ultimately wrong. Life can’t be seen through Martin’s eyes where, “a man is badly off wherever he is.”(p. 139) According to him everything is dark, tragic, and misfortunate, yet since this is how it is everywhere, there is nothing to do on the matter. Voltaire of course says that this view is wrong. Yet, he also disproves Pangloss’ theory. According to Pangloss, “everything would turn out right in some marvelous way,”(p.140) because after all, “this [was the] best of all possible worlds.” Throughout the story, he maintained that everything that happened was for the best and therefore, one should just accept all occurrences, since that was the best and only way for them to happen.

            The truth according to Voltaire is that life is similar to Adam and Eve’s situation in the garden. “When man was placed in the Garden of Eden, he was put there ‘to dress it and to keep it’, to work.”(p.143) We must take an active role in our lives and never sit back and observe like Martin and Pangloss suggested. Life is difficult, but we can improve it by working. This is why Voltaire decided to finish the book with the analogy of a farm. Candide seemed to understand that they “must go and work in the garden.”(p.144) By doing this, their farm would bear heavy crops and so would their life in general. Voltaire’s call for action is that we must work to improve our lives and the world around us, we must take control of our own fate and future. 

What is Money?

What is money? Is it a solution or a problem? Would you call it a blessing or a curse?

           When Candide reaches Paris he comes down with “a slight illness”(p.97) However since he is quite wealthy, “he was soon attended by two doctors whom he had not sent for, some intimate friends who would not leave him, and two ladies given to good works who saw that his broth was properly warmed.”(p.97) What kind of intimate friends could Candide possibly meet the instant he set foot in Paris and what kind of honest doctors could be so keen to cure a sick stranger? I’ll tell you, avaricious friends and interested doctors, that’s who. At first glance an outsider might believe that these people are friendly and helpful, yet a more detailed look will prove the exact opposite.
            As this happened, “Martin remarked: ‘I remember being ill myself during my first visit to Paris. I was very poor. But then I had no friends, no kind ladies, and no doctors, so I soon recovered.’ “(p.97) Could this mean that the doctors, friends, and ladies only aided Candide because of his rich standing? Most definitely! The only reason they even so much as thought about Candide’s wellbeing was because they realized he was affluent.
Furthermore, those that helped Candide seemed more eager to keep him sick then actually cure him. When Martin was ill and didn’t receive support he quickly recovered. On the other hand, despite all the assistance Candide obtained his sickness only gained strength. “By dint of medicines and bleeding, Candide’s disorder now became serious.”(p.97) As a result, of Candide’s large amount of money he suffered a lot more than he would have initially.
Later on, when Candide searches for a passage to England, “Three diamonds helped to make the Norman the most obliging of men.”(p.109) Of course he ultimately receives what he was looking for, yet at a much too high price. Sadly, Candide has fallen into a routine of achieving his goals by bribing and paying off others. However, he really shouldn’t have to pay his way through life and this shouldn’t be the only way for others to willingly help him.
When Candide encounters Paquette in the company of a monk he gives them money and says, “That will make them happy.”(p.117) Yet Martin disagrees and says, “It would not surprise me if those piastres of yours made them even more unhappy.”(p.117) In the end, “Pacquette and Brother Giroflée did not return to thank him.”(p.124) Proving that Candide was wrong, money isn't a way to solve problems. In fact, it never is. Many times greedy and malicious people gravitate toward it and unfortunately wealthy people many times find themselves in undesirable circumstances. Some even find themselves resolving to bribery as a means to achieve goals. Money is a difficult subject that must be treated with care and precaution, because if not it can easily lead to evil and misfortunes. 

miércoles, 15 de febrero de 2012

Watching War

“The ship’s telescopes revealed two vessels fighting about three miles away; but the wind brought them both so close to the French ship, that the passengers had the pleasure of watching the fight in comfort.”(p.93)

How do people pleasure in watching a battle? Much less find comfort in the way others ruthlessly kill each other?
As Martin and Candide voyage to Bordeaux they calmly come across this scene. Apparently, it is the most common thing to watch two ships tear each other to shreds, not do anything about it, and not fear that your ship might be attacked next. Who knew? Truthfully though, the flawed logic in this is outstanding! In reality battles are brutal and bloody and in fact the most unpleasant thing to witness.
Although at first they refer to the battle with words such as pleasure and comfort, later they seem to contradict their prior opinions. As the losing ship is swallowed by the sea, Martin says, “You see how men treat each other!”(p.93) To which Candide responds, “There is certainly something diabolical about that.”(p.93) It is true, there is definitely something diabolical about that, but even more diabolical is the fact that onlookers can observe with such apathy.  To watch fellow human beings killed and not grieve their death. To simply look on as if,  “all is for the best.” (p.20) Meanwhile, accepting this as “sufficient reason” (p.33) for their tragic fate.
Thing is, these two ships shouldn’t have been fighting in the manner that they were. Yet, it’s even a greater crime for Candide and Martin to have observed with the seemingly bored composure that they did.